Three safeguards. One law.
None of these provisions weakens a life-safety code. Each removes a single point of failure from the process that decides whether a business survives.
The problem in one paragraph
In many jurisdictions, one municipal building official can inspect a property, issue findings, deny a Certificate of Occupancy, placard the premises, and extend review indefinitely — with no peer review, no deadline enforcement, and no penalty for delay. That combination lets a single person end a business without anyone else agreeing.
Small business owners are not asking for exemptions from safety codes, and this act does not create any. It asks only that the power to close a business be shared, and that existing deadlines mean something.
This proposal applies to commercial closures and Certificate of Occupancy decisions. It does not change inspection standards, code requirements, or the grounds on which a closure may be ordered. It changes who must agree and by when.
Provision 01 · Multi-person review
The ask. No single official may order a commercial closure or deny a Certificate of Occupancy. Any closure or administrative hold exceeding 30 days must be ratified by a three-person panel.
Provision 02 · Deadlines that mean something
The ask. If a municipality misses a state-mandated review deadline without a written, code-specific safety justification, an expedited state-level review or third-party plan review begins automatically — paid for by the municipality.
Provision 03 · Protection from retaliation
The ask. Safe-harbor channels and explicit protections for business owners and licensed design professionals who report selective enforcement, profiling, or procedural delay tactics.
Model legislative text
Discussion draft · plain-language model for state or municipal adoption · to be reviewed by counsel before introduction.
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the "Dwight Carlson Reform Act."
SECTION 2. FINDINGS.
(a) A single municipal official may currently order the closure
of a commercial establishment, or deny a certificate of
occupancy, without peer review or panel ratification.
(b) State law establishes review deadlines that carry no
consequence when exceeded.
(c) Licensed design professionals may decline to document
concerns about a project, leaving business owners without
a record to appeal.
(d) The legislature finds that sharing the closure authority
among multiple qualified reviewers, and enforcing existing
deadlines, protects both public safety and due process.
SECTION 3. MULTI-PERSON REVIEW REQUIRED.
(a) No building official, inspector, or other municipal employee
shall issue a final order closing a commercial establishment,
or deny a certificate of occupancy, without ratification by a
review panel constituted under this section.
(b) The review panel shall consist of:
(1) the local or regional building official, or a designee;
(2) an independent licensed engineer or architect appointed
by the state and not employed by the municipality; and
(3) a commercial ombudsman or neutral municipal
representative designated by the chief executive.
(c) Any closure or administrative hold exceeding thirty (30) days
shall require a written finding, citing the specific code
section relied upon, that continued operation presents an
imminent risk to life safety.
(d) The panel shall convene within ten (10) business days of a
closure order. Where no imminent risk to life safety is
documented, the order shall not take effect before the panel
convenes.
(e) Panel determinations shall be in writing and shall be public
records, subject to redaction of personal contact details.
SECTION 4. ENFORCEMENT OF STATUTORY REVIEW WINDOWS.
(a) Where a municipality fails to complete review within the
period required by state law, and has not issued a written
justification citing the specific code section relied upon,
an expedited state-level review or third-party plan review
shall commence automatically.
(b) The cost of any review commenced under subsection (a) shall
be borne by the municipality and shall not be charged to the
applicant.
(c) The state agency shall publish an annual report listing each
application subject to this section and the days elapsed
beyond the statutory window.
SECTION 5. PROTECTION AGAINST RETALIATION.
(a) No municipality shall take adverse permitting action against
a business in response to a good-faith report of selective
enforcement, profiling, or procedural delay.
(b) No professional licensing board shall take adverse action
against a licensed design professional for providing a
written professional opinion concerning a permitted project.
(c) The state shall maintain a confidential intake channel for
reports described in subsections (a) and (b).
SECTION 6. REPORTING.
The state agency shall report annually on: the number of
commercial closure orders issued; the number ratified by a
review panel; the number of applications exceeding a statutory
review window; and the number of reports received under
Section 5.
Who can adopt this
Next